Tapping Into the Genuine Effect

February 16th, 2010

Connected: The Surprising Power of Social Networks and How They Shape Our Lives is not a book about social media marketing, nor is it a business or marketing book at all. However, the insights and data uncovered by co-authors and noted social scientists Nicolas Christakis, M.D, Ph.D. and James Fowler, Ph.D. are a must-read for any marketer interested in igniting word of mouth and becoming the brand of choice amongst their target consumers.

The first thing to understand is that social networks have been around pretty much since human beings have. These complex systems affect us in ways we often aren’t fully aware of – from how we choose our mate to how much weight we gain to whether we vote to purchases we make to if and how much we donate to a cause.

At the heart of this effect is the Three Degrees of Influence Rule. The authors’ research has shown that the spread of influence in social networks ripples out three degrees. Essentially, we have great effect upon and are in turn affected by friends of friends of friends. So if, for example, you have 20 social contacts and those contacts each have 20 social contacts and each of those contacts has 20 contacts, you are indirectly connected to 8,000 individuals whose habits and lifestyle influence you and over whom your choices also have impact. How much impact?

According to the authors, our friend’s friend’s friend has more influence on whether we gain weight than our spouses do. Their research has shown that if a mutual friend becomes obese it nearly triples a person’s risk of becoming obese. Those closer to the center of a social network, with many friends and contacts that cross over, have even more influence.

The assumption might be that social media would explode this effect but Christakis and Fowler’s research shows that when it comes to influence, not all friends are equal. While the average Facebook user (at the time of the printing of this book in 2009) has 110 “friends,” only a subset of these are actually close friends. In their study of Facebook pages of students at a large university on average only 6%, tagged each other in photos, which, according to the authors, indicate true social closeness and intimacy.

At Grow we call this the Genuine Effect – tapping into those networks where “friend” has a meaning that lives outside of Facebook, Twitter and Linked In, applying to those individuals whom you cross paths with in the real world – from your best girlfriend to the office mate you lunch with weekly to more casual acquaintance you might bump into at a party or school fundraiser. These genuine or real world connections hold a different currency and, as outlined in Connected, are those that actually impact our choices and behavior. Noted word of mouth measurement experts The Keller Fay Group report that even in this digital age, 77% of brand conversations are still happening face to face. Having designed and implemented influencer and word of mouth campaigns for scores of brands across a range of categories and demogrpahics we have seen the Genuine Effect in action and its power to build communities of brand advocates.

A recent story in Ad Age further illustrates the difference between on and offline friends and influence. According to the Edelman Trust Barometer, the number of people who view their friends and peers as credible sources of information about a company dropped by almost half, from 45% to 25%, since 2008. With more “friends” online ever more removed, influence becomes diluted and brands should not place value on an influencer solely by his or her count of online followers and friends.

However, while social media has not expanded the Three Degrees of Influence rule it has increased the reach and speed by which this influence spreads. It is how we elected a president and raised millions for Haiti. At Grow, we bake social media into every campaign, viewing it as a publicity layer that can help amplify influencer programs vs. replace them.

So, how do marketers effectively infiltrate social networks? By identifying and authentically connecting with those everyday influencers who are deeply networked and are looked to by their peers as credible sources of information on your category and, most importantly, connect emotionally with your brand. It’s not an automated process that can be housed in a master database or built with a mass email or acquired through a Facebook ad campaign.

To truly tap the Genuine Effect you must forge a relationship with those influencers who can truly serve as an authentic mouthpiece for your brand. Some things are still best done by hand.

Bookmark and Share

PR is Dead…again

January 29th, 2010

“PR is dead, and the media is dying.”

It’s baaack!

Apart from the melodrama of these statements, many (non-media or non-PR pros) have been quoted saying public relations, as a practice, is slowly diminishing in its overall value to business functions. Why? They claim the advent of social media has made PR obsolete, that all an organization needs to do is have its CEO tweet, pick a few “influential bloggers” to share their news with and maintain and craft relationships on their own. They also claim that PR agencies haven’t innovated enough – and at times, their criticism of the PR industry has been fair, especially when it come to sloppy practices and an inability to effectively use social media. In short, they say PR is not what it once was in terms of value.

And we respectfully disagree.

First, PR Week is reporting that over the next three years, marketers are going to spend more than $8 billion on public relations – a 55% increase over spending in 2008. Clearly those brands are seeing an increased need for PR services, as the media landscape gets more fragmented and challenging to navigate. Understanding that an industry publication may not be considered the most unbiased source to a doubter, let’s look directly at who is saying we’re “dead” and the alternatives they propose.

Andy Sacks, a blogger in Seattle who writes about entrepreneurship, recently wrote a “PR is dead” post and then offered the following tips:

Make a list of the top 10 influencers you are targeting.
Work backwards from 10 to 1 and start engaging that list in any way you can
By the time you get to #1, you should have your pitch and engagement down so you have the greatest chance of success.

As we pointed out to Mr. Sacks on Twitter, this actually proves that PR is not dead. Who makes the list of influencers? Who conducts the necessary research to identify these people and then create relationships with them? Who crafts the pitch? Your leaders can certainly do some of this lifting but it doesn’t feel strategic or streamlined. Bloggers and media alike are notoriously irritated by being pitched by someone who has not taken the time to familiarize themselves with the topic areas they cover and how they like to be approached. Is this kind of detailed and nuanced research the best use of a CEO’s time? Also, your pitch should be tight well before you get to your #1 identified influencer. Why should influencers 2 through 10 have to suffer through a mediocre attempt? To maximize success and minimize gaffes that can spread through social media like wildfire, you need dedicated and talented publicists to manage this process.

Just because this is “old news”, we do need to address the rumored demise of the press release (and also old news but “PR” doesn’t stand for “press release”). Many claim that releases as a form of media relations are a thing of the past yet we’re finding that journalists often rely on press releases as a valuable resource to help them write their stories. We’re asked all the time if we can supply a release and we recommend most of our clients to issue press releases as a document of record for major announcements. Dedicating an area on a Web site to this is hugely critical for any organization. Let’s be clear – a press release is not the key to a successful PR program, and there is no substitute for knowing how to craft and pitch a compelling story and knowing a journalist’s beat, but having the story and facts in a release remains a piece of the PR pie.

PR is still needed to set, hone, refine, evaluate and broadcast critical messages for an organization, brand or cause. And that, my friends, is why PR is alive and well, still shaping company reputations and contributing to the bottom line.

Bookmark and Share

Are Pop-up Shops So 2009?

December 22nd, 2009

Recently Women’s Wear Daily posted an article predicting that the novelty of the pop-up shop will fade in 2010, which Fast Company magazine referenced in a post today. The article cites experts who feel the trend has been overplayed, driven primarily by the recession hitting retail storefronts and driving down rents:

“Retailers might need to come up with another idea or a fresh angle for the pop-up to excite consumers. That’s key, since the main role of pop-ups is primarily to be marketing vehicles rather than drivers of significant profits and sales.”

We couldn’t agree more. As with any marketing tactic, a fresh angle and approach is critical to consumer engagement. While lower rents may have made some brands jump in who otherwise might not have considered the medium, the reality is that brands still need to continue to reach out to consumers in interesting ways to set themselves apart. Consider that although we are living in a digital world, much of what fuels social media chatter continues to be the events and experiences that happen to us offline.

We feel the pop-up shop has only begun to stretch its legs, for a multitude of reasons. When executed well, a pop-up offers a:

• Dynamic space for influencer events
• Hub for social media activity
• Backdrop for publicity and media events
• Living billboard that garners thousands of impressions from passersby
• Disruption that stops consumers in their tracks

Most importantly, pop-ups can be ideal for high-engagement products and considered purchases, allowing consumers to test-drive before they buy. Pop-ups function best when they deliver an experience that goes far beyond interesting merchandising, offering consumers a reason to walk through the door, and tell their friends. At best, a pop-up experience amplifies the product’s offerings.

One recent example is our own EA Sports Active Pop-Up Training Centers. We curated the entire experience, from start to finish, to truly take the product off the shelves and into consumers’ hands.

So brand marketers, we’d like to see more pop-ups in 2010. Pop.

Bookmark and Share

How Southern Comfort Blends Facebook with Real Life Events to Create A Buzz Loop

November 2nd, 2009

With almost 300 million worldwide users, it goes without saying that Facebook has changed the way we interact, connect and converse. In fact, Facebook posts are up nearly 200% in the last year, revealing that, as consumers, the practice of logging in, and extending our social lives online is becoming as habitual as the proverbial morning cup of coffee.

Brands now have the opportunity to be part of the daily conversation with their consumers through fan pages, thereby leveraging those fans to acquire even more. But putting up a fan page does not a loyal following make: Friends in the real world are a two-way street and online, that rule remains the same.

A recent post by Ben McConnell on the power of Facebook fan pages as a brand builder has inspired us to look a bit deeper into the use of fan pages and how they blend with real-world marketing programs to create a buzz loop. This loop rewards consumers for engaging with the brand and brings it into their lives both on- and off-line. A spirits brand we think does a great job is Southern Comfort (note: this is not a Grow Marketing client) with a current fan following of more than 150,000 brand advocates on Facebook.

picture-122

Here’s why their page commands a loyal, engaged following:

• Content co-creation
Roughly 70% of the content is all about cocktail recipes, which is a blend of SoCo recommendations and fans’ own favorites, such as the Comfort Coffee or Southern Margarita.
picture-16

Fans also submit photos of the product in unexpected or surprising places. One user sent in a photo of a bottle tucked in the sand on the beach, describing her perfect summer beach vacation. The SoCo status update (and Fan Page administrator) thanks the user who took the photo, shares it with the plugged-in Fan Page audience, and then poses, “Where have you spent your summer vacation?” to the tune of more than 190 respondents.

• Leveraging real world sponsorships and events
Southern Comfort participates in many interesting and exciting events around the world, such as concerts, sporting events and selected club nights. Through their fan page they leverage the credibility of their participation and amplify the reach way beyond their on-the-ground audience, while rewarding those who attended the events in person with valuable recognition. They wisely translate the interest to data capture by offering a way to sign up for VIP events and get news via the SoCo newsletter in the future. It’s about coming back and making it feel like you’re the VIP.

• Contests
Never underestimate the power of swag – or cold, hard cash. And SoCo smartly asks for engagement in order to get a shot at that reward. Fans can enter to win $100 each week by providing a “Party Tip of the Week” that is used – and evangelized – on the site; this is a clever and affordable way to engage with fans and encourage them to return again and again.
picture-14

• Soliciting feedback
SoCo is constantly asking fans for their thoughts, opinions and favorite “SoCo” moments to further incite participation and benefit from an informal focus group that reflects their most passionate target.

The power of online engagement? SoCo gets it. According to MediaPost, SoCo’s commitment to the digital platform through its U.S advertising efforts proves that this brand knows where to find their consumers.

For this brand, at the end of the day, all of these aforementioned tactics provide stellar content and tools for engagement while creating a continual buzz loop across all of their marketing efforts. SoCo’s smartest move (in our ever humble, but well-seasoned opinion) is that they recognize that consumers don’t separate their online and offline worlds – for them it’s just one big brand experience.

Bookmark and Share

Social Media Changing The Parent-Child Relationship of Brands

October 22nd, 2009

If you missed the flap about Amp’s new iPhone app last week it’s probably because you were following the Balloon Boy debacle, or were on vacation on a remote, tropical isle (hopefully the latter). Essentially, the app was deemed offensive to women by some and a harmless joke by others. We’re not going to weigh in on the specifics of this campaign – that’s been done ad nauseam, but how diffusion brands work with their parent companies got us thinking about how social media is impacting marketing strategies across all consumer categories.

Once upon a time (pre-social media and certainly pre-Internet) consumers weren’t generally aware of the relationship between parent brands, such as Pepsi or Unilever, and their many “children.” Estée Lauder was thought of as one beauty brand, not the “mother” of Clinique, Origins, La Mer and a host of others. This lack of visibility into the inner workings of the industry allowed parent brands to launch diffusion lines to create relevancy with and gain revenue from new audiences while retaining their loyal following.

Now consumers are not only increasingly aware of the power of their voices, as evidenced by the FTC caring enough about the blogosphere to create guidelines, they also have much more transparency into brand relationships. As such, the actions of the children will most certainly come to rest at the parents’ feet. Elevated inter-brand awareness creates a different set of challenges, and opportunities, and requires a new approach to communications that takes that transparency into account with “if/then” scenario building around edgier campaigns.

Note: Pepsi is a client of Grow Marketing, but not the Amp brand.

Bookmark and Share

To Understand The Power of Influencer Marketing, Just Look To The Consumer Within

September 9th, 2009

Ten percent of the population is credited with influencing the remaining 90% with what to purchase, consume and experience. By tapping into the right 10%, we reach the few who fuel the many.

Brands used to measuring ROI in CPM, CPC and other cost-analysis acronyms developed for traditional media and online marketing sometimes have trouble wrapping their heads around Influencer Marketing and what makes it so effective.

There are many metrics and multipliers that can help quantify the reach and impact achieved with an influencer program. However, one of the most powerful ways is to bring it down to the personal level with a simple reminder about how each of us receive and act on recommendations for an array or products and services from the go-to people in our social networks, every day. We call these “influencer moments.” Here’s how it works:

Gabrey, one of our co-founders, sees a new bakery open on our street called Pacific Puffs. Not only are the puffs themselves fantastic but two adorable brothers and their cousin went in on the shop together using their grandma’s recipe to create the decadent treats. From Gabrey’s first taste, they made their way to 4 dinner parties around the Bay Area (great hostess gift) that had around 10 attendees each. They also ended up at Grow’s offices for three meetings with clients as well as a monthly team meeting. Of course people loved the product, but they also really connected with the story. The idea of supporting a new business sharing Grandma’s family recipe with the public for the first time just makes you feel a little more invested, and connected. Yet another reason to stop there vs. any number of bakeries in San Francisco.

Has every Pacific Puffs customer shared the baked goods, and their story, with their network like Gabrey did? Probably not. But not because they didn’t enjoy their experience. Perhaps they didn’t chat up the founders and learn the bakery’s back-story, or have four dinner parties booked on their social calendar in need of a tasty hostess gift. Imagine if Pacific Puffs made a concerted effort to find other people like Gabrey, gave them a thoughtful tasting experience and created a special hostess gift offering, ideal to take to dinner parties? How much faster could their reputation spread – and sales grow?

This is one example of the viral marketing that happens in each of our lives, every day. You might be wondering how many people you can actually reach with an Influencer campaign. Does it really scale?

Here’s a small taste:
Sinupret for Kids
Pepsi’s Tava

Bookmark and Share

Even Traditional Media Looks To Non-Traditional Marketing

August 24th, 2009

Evidence that non-traditional marketing is on the rise: According to a recent article in BrandWeek, even “traditional media” are adopting new, experiential platforms to promote their brands.

CBS is hitting the digital ground to promote a new show in nail salons; ABC is hosting community screenings as intimate gatherings for consumers to experience the lineups. For Fox, viewership of a pilot exceeded expectations, so sporadic “pop up” screenings and partnerships throughout the summer will keep the buzz going through Fall.

The fourth major network (NBC, we had to mention them, too if we’re talking traditional media!) is launching stunts and sponsorships through social media. [They’re not all about the free content, however, because Facebook users must invite 10 of their friends to become fans in order to attain pre-launch exclusive material]. NBC is embracing word-of-mouth to generate buzz and providing incentives to pass along – both quality signs that the network is embracing non-traditional ways to engage and interact.

Forward-thinking executives from top brands in a range of lifestyle categories are recognizing that there are new ways of opening up dialogue and directly engaging consumers where they live, work and play. Where is your brand in the conversation? Are you talking, listening or standing on the sidelines? Time to jump in.

Bookmark and Share

BlogHer 09 and Constructive Collaboration

July 31st, 2009

This year was my first BlogHer Conference and honestly, I wasn’t exactly sure what to expect. I do know that with the shrinking of print media and the increasing influence and diversity of voices in the blogosphere I was going to hear lots of perspectives and opinions. And BlogHer did not disappoint. Not during and certainly not after with the online flap that has run the gamut in tone from supportive to constructive to plain mean-spirited.

When I returned, several colleagues asked me about my impressions of the conference and the word “adolescence” kept coming to mind. Now before that is perceived as a negative, let me explain. Adolescence is this wonderful and sometimes painful in-between time, where thoughts and behaviors range from immature to surprisingly wise. It is a time of transition, not an end result. To think that the founders of BlogHer started this grassroots movement in 2005 (funded by their own credit cards) and that the explosion of social media has so accelerated the growth rate and influence of women bloggers that their 2009 conference would attract major sponsors, such as Proctor & Gamble, PepsiCo and Wal-Mart and keynote speakers that included renowned media mavens and cultural game-changers such as Tina Brown, Donna Byrd and Ilene Chaiken. And that while these new, famous contributors were heartily embraced one of the most well received and buzzed about keynotes featured bloggers, famous only in their own circles, reading and sharing their work. That’s a pretty amazing trajectory, and scope. For a great summary of the history of BlogHer and its evolution, check out co-founder Jory Des Jardin’s insightful post.

But while technology can move at warp speed, human beings still get growing pains.

SponsorGate, Mommyblogger Mania, Girls Behaving Badly. I don’t need to go into the details of the controversies. We’re all more than familiar, but if you missed it check out these articles from Ad Age, and NPR or visit BlogHer for the basics.

Disappointment and even anger ultimately imply caring. The BlogHer backlash above all else is an indication of how much women value this community. In the spirit of that caring, sharing grievances should also include making a couple of suggestions about what might make things better. The best example of this attitude in action comes from BlogHer’s “Women of Color and Marketing” panel, which was one of the most informative sessions I’ve attended at any conference in a long time.

Hosted by Heather Barmore from No Pasa Nada, Karen Walrond from Chookooloonks, Kelly Wickham from Mocha Momma and Stefania Pomponi Butler from City Mama, this session was a lively discussion on how women of color and marketers could work more productively and respectfully with each other. Solutions weren’t always clear. Some minority bloggers expressed frustration at being passed off to the niche multicultural agency while others felt a specialization was necessary in order to communicate with them effectively. At one point a white PR rep stood up and shared that she would love to work on multicultural campaigns but clients did not feel their mostly Caucasian staff could be effective with these audiences so they were never awarded the business. Murmurs of “wow” and “I had no idea” went around the room. A similar surprised response occurred when a travel blogger recounted a story of a PR firm who indicated a client would be interested in a partnership if she could sound “more Latina” in her writing.

No quick fixes were identified but everyone heard each other out because they went in assuming that anyone participating in the conversation had a shared interest in moving the dialogue forward. It is this spirit that will move BlogHer beyond adolescence into fulfilling the founders’ vision “to create the space where we women who blog can create our own opportunities–for education, exposure, community, economic empowerment, or all of the above.”

Read the co-founders’ response to the controversy and submit BlogHer feedback here.

(note: Tami Anderson, an account director at Grow was at the BlogHer Conference in Chicago last weekend as an attendee. In the spirit of transparency PepsiCo, a Grow client, was a sponsor of BlogHer and Grow had a team on site who managed the streamlined shipping services, aka home.propelled, offered to attendees on behalf of Propel)

Bookmark and Share

Parenting Mashup

July 20th, 2009

Traditional gender roles are blurring and this progression has been building for a while. Quietly, while media and consumers have been delving into the topics of motherhood, women shattering (or significantly cracking) the glass ceiling and what it means for them to “have it all,” men have become more active fathers, picked up a larger share of household chores and, in some cases, taken on the role of primary caregiver.  In fact, according to the U.S. Census Bureau, in the last 11 years the amount of stay-at-home dads has doubled. (more…)

Bookmark and Share

We Don’t Need The FTC To Tell Us The Importance of Transparency

July 12th, 2009

Everyone is talking about mommy bloggers and credible product reviews.

Also, the Associated Press reported that the FTC is planning to set new guidelines to increase transparency in the blogosphere, allowing the agency to fine bloggers for promoting products and brands in exchange for payment without disclosure of those relationships.  The companies fronting the “pay to play” dollars would be on the hook as well.

But one size does not fit all in this equation. How much of an unbiased view do consumers expect from bloggers, who, unlike journalists, often become popular for having a distinct voice and opinion?  How do brands integrate appropriately?

We all know mommy bloggers have exploded in popularity, with brands from Apple and Volvo to Kleenex and Kraft seeking their positive endorsement and access to their large, loyal audiences of, well, other mommies.  As reported in this AdWeek post, Gretchen Vogelzang and Paige Heninger of the popular MommyCast video series, which has drawn over 250,000 viewers for a single episode, are among the most coveted of mommy bloggers, gaining sponsorship from Johnson & Johnson, Procter & Gamble, and State Farm.  Online marketing expert Holly Buchanan’s blog post shows the flip side of this – popular mom bloggers whose colorful language and honesty draw large audiences but make some brands hesitant to integrate.

The issue here is credibility. If a mom reads another’s blog and trusts a mom-to-mom recommendation, how does she feel when she finds out that that it was a sponsored review?  It should go without saying, but being up-front about those relationships from the beginning is absolutely essential.  We’ve already observed influential tweeters, such as @savvyauntie adding a #spon hashtag to sponsored messages to make those relationships clear. Don’t forget, bloggers are essentially building a brand, too, and to maintain their integrity, transparency is critical.

Bookmark and Share